Showing posts with label choices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label choices. Show all posts

5.22.2007

Moral Dilemma

I’ve recently encountered a personal problem that I could use some advice on and it relates to issues of politics and values that we’ve been discussing. I’ve been approached by CENTRA, a private company that works for the US military, to edit a “smart card” that they are distributing to Marines in Ethiopia. A smart card provides basic cultural information that is intended to facilitate interactions between marines and Ethiopians (see: http://www.mediafire.com/?ezznyjz1n3d for more details). My understanding is that US marines are advising the Ethiopian military concerning their recent invasion of Somalia. Essentially the Ethiopian government has been roped into fighting our war on terror in exchange for our ignoring their human rights abuses and importation of weapons from North Korea. I oppose the US military presence in the Horn of Africa for a number of reasons that I can go into in more detail if you’re interested.

So, clearly there is good reason not to participate in this project. On the other hand, the marines will be in Ethiopia regardless of what I do. Perhaps by getting involved in the production of information that will guide the actions of the marines I can reduce the damage done by their presence. It is debatable how much these cards actually could have an influence the behavior of marines, but assuming that they have at least some impact I think it is reasonable to assume they could do some good.

By participating in this project would I be legitimizing a military action that I strongly oppose?

Does the possibility of shaping marine views of Ethiopians in a direction of my choosing outweigh this possibility?

Will the impact of these smart cards be so negligible that it doesn’t really matter what I do?

I’m not sure if this is relevant but CENTRA has offered to pay me $500 for what would amount to at most one day of work.

I look forward to your advice.