It sends shivers up my spine. “Paralyzed by electricity! It was the guns of rock and roll! It was a sound that was out of control! Burnsiiiiide!!!!!”
The Rats off of their early 1980’s album In a Desperate Red. This is what I mean by a new language for politics. On the album, Burnside is preceded by a song called Working Class and followed by Come On Toody in which the band leader Fred Cole laments his wife Toody’s inability to get out of the house in a timely manner – “Come on Toody, Why’s it always take you so long?” If this is a political language it is extremely specific. It speaks to that handful of people who know about a street called Burnside and understand why it might have something to do with electricity flowing through your veins. Specificity has good and bad qualities. For those of us who are participating in the same language game as Fred Cole it makes the song take on an amazing power. For those who have never experienced Burnside it is more or less meaningless. Maybe you get what he’s saying but it’s not the same as having lived the street. So, this means of communication has limits.
A person might also question the actual message of this song, but I will assume that after all of our preceding discussion that this is no longer an issue. Burnside is no less of a call to action and values than appeals to strength and equality.
The problem is one of sacrificing the power of localism for a larger audience. Both are important and sacrificing one for the other would be a mistake. Fred and Toody Cole later formed two-thirds of Dead Moon, a band that consistently sought to use local symbols in order to create an international set of values. The title and chorus of the Dead Moon song 54/40 or Fight, refers to the slogan that was used to claim the independence of Oregon territory from the British in the 1840’s. Previously the territory was administered by both the British and Americans and 54/40 was the line of latitude that marked the northern border of Oregon territory. While the US did take control of much of Oregon territory they had to settle for the 49th parallel, which is now the northern border of Washington state. The song has little in the way of historical reference. Rather it is a song about being pushed until you can take no more. In some ways it is a song of rebellion not unlike other classics like Twisted Sister’s We’re Not Gonna Take It. However, both the Dead Moon lifestyle (being old, putting out your own records in mono, wearing black) gave them a credibility that kept irony at a minimal level. Despite the Oregoncentric nature of Dead Moon’s lyrics their biggest fan base was in Germany.
Dead Moon and The Rats never sold themselves as an “Oregon” band in the manner that ZZ Top catapulted themselves with the symbol of Texas. Perhaps the notion of staying true to one’s roots enabled them to expand their audience, but there was never a point when it seemed that Dead Moon was sticking close to Clackamas in order ensure their credibility and therefore sell more albums in Germany. Even with international acclaim, the localism of Dead Moon was maintained.
If there is a new language it must be one that combines specificity and mass appeal. It’s necessary to grab hold of a symbol with the power of Burnside that people all over the world can recognize. This is why peace, love, and war are so popular. This is also why peace, love, and war fail to generate any real passion in so many people – they are too abstract. This is a problem, but as 54/40 or Fight (sorry no digital copy to post) illustrates there is no inherent barrier to constructing symbols that are locally specific and appeal to people in different places. The political success of the left depends on generating such symbols that are rooted in place but are capable of transcendence as well
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
Still having trouble with making links but here are downloads to all of the songs by The Rats that I mentioned:
Burnside:
http://www.mediafire.com/?4x1cngedz3y
Working Class:
http://www.mediafire.com/?6zhzztj4mvn
Come On Toody:
http://www.mediafire.com/?dxmzuydmdwi
Let me know if you have trouble accessing these.
Well, DM, I think I'm beginning to get your ZZ Top post now. An important element of many aesthetic objects is the place they depict or evoke. When you take that away, you change--often for the worse--the aesthetic quality of that object. Hence, ZZ Top lost something as their association with Texas weakened. (Correct me if I don't have this quite right... the ZZ post isn't fresh in my mind right now.)
There's a similar, and familiar, phenomenon in ethical thinking. We tend to care more about those we are familiar with. We also tend to care more about people when we can put a face on them, attach a story to them. There's a good reason UNICEF literature always includes heart-rending pictures of emaciated kids. This sort of selective caring is irrational given general commitments to caring about all who need the care, but it seems to be a fact about how our psychology works, and one ignores it at the peril of the cause you are trying to promote. Peace, Love, and War fail to motivate us to the degree they should, not because we don't care about them, but because we have a hard time putting a face on them. Hence our discussion of aesthetics and politics, and DM's concern with the aesthetic quality that an association with places adds to a thing.
I am going to question the actual message of the song "Burnside." I don't see the political relevance of it. It may reflect your values, and may call you to action (although what action, I'm not sure... hopefully a good one), and the song is valuable as such. But I don't think that fact alone makes it political. In another post I agreed that the Sonic Youth song "Sister" (?) could qualify as political since it's maybe about how you love, and how you love is one of those things that some people want to legislate. You'll have to show me a similar connection in regards to these songs. And even granting that the SY song is political, I think it's only very slightly political. I don't see how an effective "new language" of politics could come out of it.
Am I right in thinking that you do work on stuff that has to do with music and politics in Africa, DM? It would be cool to learn about some concrete examples of how music or art provided something like "a new language of politics" that really did make a difference.
And I enjoyed reading about The Rats and Dead Moon.
'54/40 Or Fight':
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4nVmnPJgB0U
http://youtube.com/watch?v=Xg4ETeBVNn4
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vBdNu6vrttY
Post a Comment